Prompt 2: Historical Parallels in 1984


Historical Parallels in 1984

  1. The first example that was very obvious to me as to drawing up an actual historical parallel based on what I read in the novel 1984 by George Orwell was the whole concept of what the story revolves around. The place Oceania, which is where all the characters live in, is set up where the government (Big Brother) is always watching over all of the citizens so that it can control just about every single aspect of the people’s lives. The saying “Big Brother Is Watching You” is repeated every so often throughout the novel for the purposes of dramatic effect and emphasis. The parallel is that the Soviet Union established a totalitarian state of government under Joseph Stalin in the 1940’s. I was largely reminded very much of that while reading through the novel.
  2. My research also told me that George Orwell had written an essay that was entitled Why I Write, in which he explains that all the “serious work” that he had written ever since the Spanish Civil War was “written, directly or indirectly, against totalitarianism and for democratic socialism.” What this means is that we can look at the novel clearly opposing totalitarianism. Also, although I have not read the book Animal Farm by George Orwell, I looked it up and realized that Orwell mentions his heavy dislike and criticism of totalitarian systems within it as well.
  3. Another specific event that is in the text which reflects an actual historical event is the often mentioned Two Minutes Hate. This event is described as a small but important event in which the citizens of Oceania are instructed to face the telescreen and are pretty much forced to have feelings of hate towards Eurasia. In a much broader sense, it can be described as a form of nationalism for Oceania. What George Orwell had done was based this concept off of when Stalin had held events where he would scrutinize his enemies.
  4. Also, I found out that Orwell had worked for BBC at one time in his life. During this time when he was employed for this company, BBC was headed and leaded by the Ministry of Information. George Orwell had admitted to a man named Malcolm Muggeridge that this was the basis of what lead to his creation of the Ministry of Truth in his book 1984.
  5. Supposedly, the world of which the novel takes place in appears to reflect and present various aspects of the social and political life of the United Kingdom as well as the U.S.A. According to certain reports, George Orwell was said to have based the book so that it resembled the poor economy and weak conditions of the British Empire. Although specific details as to how this is exactly so, are lacking, one can conclude that his novel has quite a lot to do with his personal life.
  1. Perhaps another great point in drawing conclusions about insightful historical connections is the topic of the newspaper within the story. The party called Ingsoc has a newspaper that is called the Times whereas Orwell also seemed to be quite interested in reading a newspaper with this very same title during his younger days. This newspaper was and is regarded as the voice of the ruling class of the British. Also, major emphasis is placed upon the language of newspeak throughout the novel.
  2. The concept of the thought police in this story is mentioned quite frequently within the story as yet another measure that is taken by Big Brother in order to limit the freedom of the citizens and maintain strict order. After doing some research, I had concluded that the thought police is very much so similar to the Gestapo or NKVD which were secret police for Nazi Germany (Gestapo) and for Stalin’s Russia (NKVD). Every single time the thought police is brought up, it is made out to be very fearful if the rules of the government are broken.
  3. One of the more obvious historical parallels that I was able to pick up on was all the use of propaganda in the novel. Thoughts of a totalitarian- run state had entered my mind right away, allowing me to receive a vivid picture of what the society of Oceania looked like. The author Orwell is consistently making references to some propaganda such as the big photos of the middle-aged man with the caption saying “Big Brother Is Watching You.” Orwell uses very effective techniques to instill a clear description of a strong authoritarian style of government through his mentions of propaganda.
  4. “Doublethink” is another concept that is a part of the Oceanic society that is pretty complex and involves a lot of thought, but it can easily be committed by a person if they were not careful. Basically, what I got out of it was that it is when a person manipulates their own mind to lie or use logic against the beliefs and principles of Big Brother, or similar activities. The government took this very seriously and did not want it being used in the wrong way. While reading about doublethink, I was reminded of how governments such as the one in the story would take strong measures to make their citizens think alike and in a certain way.
  5. The last very obvious thing that I had noticed in this exciting and interesting book of 1984 by George Orwell that I could parallel to actual historical events or involvements was just the general way that things are constructed there in Oceania especially being the exact and very particular way in which the innocent people were required to pay so much mandatory respect and honor towards the worshiping of Big Brother and the government accepted no less. If these proper actions were not taken, then much violent action was to be done and the citizens knew it as well. They had to live their lives in constant fear of being vanished and the fact that they even once existed would be wiped away as well. There have been countless amounts of governments throughout the subject of world history that have set up very strict governments in which violence or just about any matter was used in order to achieve society to be the way the government wanted it to be, i.e. Nazi Germany, totalitarian USSR, etc. I was reminded of this all to a very large extent while reading 1984. 

Research Prompts for 11/27


Research Prompt 1

1984: Characters, Space and Plot

By this point, you should be able to easily identify the seven or eight most important characters in the text (that we know of). Present brief descriptions of each. Draw a map of the world that Winston inhabits, including the principal locations covered in the text so far. Write out a brief description (less than fifty words) of the plot in three different ways: first, focusing on Winston; second, focusing on the Party control; third, focusing on the dynamic between Winston and Julia. Email the characters descriptions, map, and plot synopses before the start of class.


Research Prompt 2

1984 Bibliographical Entry

Pick one of the secondary texts from the bibliography that Stacy put together and create an annotated entry for the text, just as we did with The Brothers Karamazov. Purdue's OWL site provides examples and ideas about how to construct a bibliographical entry:
http://owl.english.purdue.edu/owl/resource/614/03/

Please complete and email before class starts.

Research Prompt 3

What is at stake?

Pick out five moments of major conflict in the novel. Make a chart that illustrates what is at stake for the individuals presented in the novel in each moment you pick out. Describe, in each instance, what do the individuals stand to lose and what do they stand to gain? Follow up your thoughts with a hundred words on the motivations and forces that operate on a psychological level in the novel. Please complete and email before class starts.



Bibliography for 1984

Articles : Stony Brook Scholarly article database 

Rodden, John.Rossi, John P. “If He Had Lived, or A Counterfactual Life of George Orwel”
Prose Studies; Apr2010, Vol. 32 Issue 1, p1-11, 11p,
Database: Humanities International Complete, Accession Number:51376567


Tyner, James. “Self and space, resistance and discipline: a Foucauldian reading of George Orwell's 1984”
Social & Cultural Geography. Mar2004, Vol. 5 Issue 1, p129-149. 21p.

Rankin, David. “ORWELL'S INTENTION IN 1984”
English Language Notes, Mar1975, Vol. 12 Issue 3, p188, 5p ; ORWELL, George, 1903-1950

Stansky, Peter. “George Orwell and the Origins of "1984"
Modern Language Quarterly. Mar76, Vol. 37 Issue 1, p101. 3p

McKown, Delos B. “CREATION SCIENCE: NEWSPEAK BEFORE ITS TIME”   ETC: A Review of General Semantics. Oct2006, Vol. 63 Issue 4, p437-443. 7p.


Books : Stony Brook Library

Howe, Irving. 1984 Revisited: Totalitarianism in our Century
Harper & Rowe Publishers, NewYork 1983

Shoham, Sholomo Giora. Rosenstiel, Francis. And He Loved Big Brother: Man, State and Society Question
The Macmillian Press Ltd. London 1985

Jensen, Ejner J. The Future of Nineteen Eighty-Four
Ann Arbor University of Michigan Press 1987

Davison, Peter. Literary Lives George Orwell(1996)
St. Martin’s Press, Scholarly and Reference Division 175 Fifth Ave NY,NY

Oldsey, Bernard. Browne, Joseph. Critical Essays on George Orwell
G.K. Hall & Co. Boston, Massachusetts 1986

Themes in the novel

Identity
In the novel, sex is primarily looked down upon by the Party. It itself can be interpreted as a form of expression and individuality. This is intertwined with the theme of Identity. A more obvious explanation for this restriction is the relationships that would be developed as a result of sexual relations threatened the Party by creating a stronger bond from one individual to another individual rather than the party itself.  The Party wanted to control sex as a primary tool to be used by the party for further control of individuals under it.  “The aim of the party was not merely to prevent men and women from forming loyalties which it might not be able to control. It’s real undeclared purpose was to remove all pleasure from the sexual act….The only recognized purpose of marriage was to beget children for the service of the party.” (65) Julia who appears later in the book, seems to have a hold on her identity,  had frequently participated in sexual exploits despite governing rule and the irony of her membership to the Junior Anti-Sex League.
Double Thinking
The main character utilizes double think to not only question the Party but to question himself. The idea of double thinking is considered completely and utterly taboo to the Party because any kind of double thinking was considered a direct challenge to the Party’s authority. “It was like a single equation with two unknowns. It might very well be that literally every word in the history books, even the things that one accepted without question, was pure fantasy. For all he knew there might never have been any such law as the jus primae noctis, or any such creature as a capitalist, or any such garment as a top hat.” (74-75) It appears that Winston has been growing more and fonder of double thinking and questioning the Party in his thoughts.
Memory
The theme of Double think also coincided with the main character’s Memory within certain aspects of the novel. “That was ten- eleven years ago. Today, probably, he would have kept that photograph. It was curious that the fact of having held it in his fingers seemed to him to make a difference even now, when the photograph itself as well as the event it recorded, was only memory. Was the Party’s hold upon the past less strong, he wondered, because a piece of evidence which existed no longer had once existed?” (79) This quote signifies the reality that it is impossible for the Party to completely control a person’s mind. Despite the destruction of the evidence. Winston remembers the people and events which are still ingrained in his mind, although lack of evidence made him doubt the memory. Winston’s job of deleting people from records who were once part of the Party but were vaporized is important because although he is wiping them from archive he is the one doing the action of deleting so he is able to have the memory of evidence.
Continuity
“…she did not understand that to push an inconvenient person over a cliff solves nothing. ‘Actually it would have made no difference,’ he said. ‘Then why are you sorry you didn’t do it?’ ‘Only because I prefer a positive to a negative. In this game we’re playing we can’t win.’” (135) This represents the continuity of Winston’s nature. At this point in the he is still too afraid to act on desires considering that he might as well be dead if he said anything that would offend the Party. It appears that the continuity in his character will last because he believes in the continuity of the power of the Party. The intimidation and manipulation still restricts Winston from gaining any courage to take a stand against the government this far in the novel. Later I feel the continuity will end and Winston will finally act on his thoughts and urges and take a stand against the Party.
Public Sphere
“It was no use. He turned around. A blonde silly faced young man named Wilsher, whom he barely knew was inviting him with a smile to a vacant place at his table. It was not safe to refuse. After having been recognized, he could not go sit at a table with an unattended girl. It was too noticeable.” ( 112) This is an example of the public sphere in that everyone’s lives are open to everyone else’s and the party. Whistleblowing was encouraged by the Party to its citizens and any suspicious activity of a neighbor would be reported for the good of the Party. This can refer to the neighbor backstabbing during Nazi rule in Germany. Neighbors would report on each other as seen with German citizens exposing and handing over Jewish people to the Nazi’s out of fear for their own image to the Nazi government. The use of fear and oppression will filter out those opposed in view or action.

1984 and Contingency

Read through Breanna's research on chapter eight of Contingency, Irony, and Solidarity. Then, look through Orwell's 1984 to find at least five moments in the text, other than those that Rorty mentions, that support the key points of Breanna's research. Explain how each moment relates to Rorty's points and present a short argument summarizing what is most worthwhile about Rorty's concepts in understanding the text. Email your research before class starts.

1. ‘We're destroying words—scores of them, hundreds of them, every day. We're cutting the language down to the bone. The Eleventh Edition won't contain a single word that will become obsolete before the year 2050.'
The moment when Syme and Winston discuss the reduction of language ties right into rority’s point about despising intellectuals that tell us the truth is not out there and that it is a function of the language we use.
2. 'No,' he said a little more hopefully, 'no; that's quite true. They can't get inside you. If you can FEEL that staying human is worthwhile, even when it can't have any result whatever, you've beaten them.'
I feel this line ties in with Rority’s point about how insistence in a prior belief can keep you going in tight situations. While Winston and Julia discuss what will become of them they stumble upon the idea that so long as they keep their desires in their hearts they can’t be beaten by torture or the machine.
3. There is a moment when Syme asks Winston is he went to see the hanging of prisoners. Winston replies that he would go to see it on television. There is also a moment earlier in which children want to see the hanging as well and are disappointed at not being able to do so.

This plays on Rority’s point on re-describing events that should be ghastly to the average person. Over time the characters have come to find torture as a mode of entertainment not the reality of what it really is.
4. There is a time while Winston is recollecting after being hit by the parsons boy, he notes that families are no longer what we consider families today but have been torn apart and now work against each other.
Rority mentions that Obrien talks about tearing down social structures and language to humiliate people. This in turn must help to keep them in check. Tearing the family structure down gives most characters in the novel no social support leaving everyone essentially helpless.  
5. There is a moment when Winston considers that the only way the party can stay in control is if there are enough paralyzingly stupid people to keep them in power.

I believe this ties into Rority’s comment about there not existing any individuals because people only follow what society tells them to do.

I feel that Rority’s comments help to make orwells motives a little more clear. I believe what's more pressing is how this book is basically the playbook of the future political and judicial order. Personally I feel Roritys comments make it easier to see how orwells notions come to play in our current society. I mean Rority makes a comment about men of great charisma and intellect being capable of monstrous things; what makes our leaders any different. Just today we have the senate trying to push a bill to let the intelligence arm data mine your email. How long till they stare back at us through the monitor, the technology is already there. The laws exist that allow indefinite detention without due process  but they'll never mention it on tv, the language is already disappearing from such parodies as tv news programs. Only small changes need to be made to the history of our modern times and as Rority points out we'll be looking at Orwell like he was a fool blabbering about nonsense than somone trying to warn us of our liberties. We gave the peace prize to somone who increased the scope of war, the majority don't know what the NDAA is and many are, whether economically or socially, trapped where they are. War is peace,freedom is slavery and ignorance is strength; we may have already crossed the rubicon.

Research Prompts for 11/20

Research Prompt 1

Imagery in 1984

Just as we've already done for The Brothers Karamazov, put together a slide show presentation to represent the physical-visual space, as you imagine it, in 1984. Compile about twenty images that you feel reflect the events, images, mood, characters, and tone of the novel. Create a slide show of these images. Prepare notes that briefly explain how each image reflects the novel. Email the notes and slide show before class begins.

Research Prompt 2

Historical Parallels in 1984

The novel is understood to make references to actual twentieth century events by many readers. List at least ten fictionalized historical realities in the text and compare them with actual historical realities. Read through the foreword for some ideas about how to interpret the events of the novel. Your research task is to present information about actual historical events and conditions that serve as a background to the novel. Email your research notes by the start of class.

Research Prompt 3

1984: Characters, Space and Plot

By this point, you should be able to easily identify the seven or eight most important characters in the text (that we know of). Present brief descriptions of each. Draw a map of the world that Winston inhabits, including the principal locations covered in the text so far. Write out a brief description (less than fifty words) of the plot in three different ways: first, focusing on Winston; second, focusing on the Party control; third, focusing on the dynamic between Winston and Julia. Email the characters descriptions, map, and plot synopses before the start of class.

1984 and Resistance

Orwell's novel presents a protagonist consumed with the desire to understand the present's relationship with the past. He places himself in danger, in harms way, by walking among the proles, speaking to them about the past and purchasing items that carry historical weight. Winston's desire to understand the historical takes the novel out of the present life of the Party member. In today's reading assignment, Winston not only writes about thoughts that fall outside of Ingsoc, he spends most of the time wandering in areas, physically and emotionally outside of Ingsoc. He speaks with an elderly man in the pub, probing for questions about a past of which the interrogated seems ignorant. He returns to the shop where he first wet his thirst for historical by buying the notebook. During this second visit he not only purchases a second object, a purposeless englassed piece of corral, he also transgresses with plans to return as he explores the second story. It is when he leaves the second-hand shop that he notes the suspicious woman in the area, incoincidentally close to his very much out her world shopping. 

The novel soon makes evident that the foreshadowing presented in regards to the woman has not been about investing in her as a betrayer of Winston. Rather, the foreshadowing (highlighting her involvement in Winton's life yet waiting to explain why) with regards to the woman with the scarlet sash was constructed to add weight to the revelation that she has feelings for him, as is revealed when she makes herself fall in his presence that he might help her to arise, allowing her the opportunity to slip him a note of affection. That the fulfillment of their emotions takes a few weeks to reach allows another representation of the forces of control at play in the world of the novel, especially under the control of the Party system. The exploration of their feelings for each other only really finds expression once the two have left the urban center, and this only after elaborate maneuvers to hide their directions and intentions from Party surveillance. In the first part of the text, the question explored was: how does party control affect verbal activities (talking, reading, thinking). In this next section, the novel explores how one might physically navigate through party controls, whether by walking in crowds, making oneself trip, not speaking one on one in view of the surveillance systems or fellow party members--only if your mouth appears not to be moving, ducking into crowds, and, importantly as Julia propounds, yelling loudly with them.

In the beginning of today's reading, Winston discusses how he, at times in his professional work, comes across information that undermines the Party's official record, noting a particular instance when three Party members who were supposedly off conspiring with another state were shown photographed in New York. Winston, then, represents the possibility and power of verbal resistance, whether in the information he finds, in his own writing, or in his own thinking and memory. In a complementary way, Julia represents the capacity and possibility of physical resistance: the best way to remain undetected is be very busy at work, in Party service, and in doing all of the little things. In doing all of the little things, no one suspects you for having trespassed bigger things. Julia's sexual exploits with multiple Party members attests to her ability to physical navigate through the Party's controls. Her exploits represent--for Winston, at least--a paramount of corruption and resistance. Winston celebrates any form of corruption that weakens the Party's  hold, whether verbal or physical. 

Research Prompts for 11/18

Research Prompt 1

Contingency and 1984


Read through Breanna's research on chapter eight of Contingency, Irony, and Solidarity. Then, look through Orwell's 1984 to find at least five moments in the text, other than those that Rorty mentions, that support the key points of Breanna's research. Explain how each moment relates to Rorty's points and present a short argument summarizing what is most worthwhile about Rorty's concepts in understanding the text. Email your research before class starts.

Research Prompt 2

A bibliography for 1984


Just as I put a bibliography together for The Brothers Karamazov, you are to put a bibliography together for Orwell's 1984. Follow the pattern started in The Brothers Karamazov bibliography, which contains both scholarly articles as well as books found in the Stony Brook University Library. You should have at least five of each on the bibliography. Be sure to follow MLA citation guidelines when formatting each entry. Email your research before class starts.


Research Prompt 3

Themes in the novel

Following the pattern established in the lecture from last Thursday, reading chapters 6-8 of book one and chapters 1-3 of book two, pay attention to moments in the text that stand out in how they contribute to a theme. Compile five or more quotes and explain over several paragraphs how they contribute to a theme. Email your research before class starts.

1984: Memory and Ethics

Ethics and Memory


Concepts

public sphere
archive
memory
double-think
truth (right and wrong)
construction
irony
identity
continuity



1984



 “1984” presents a dystopic future, however, the the text focuses on the dystopic nature of the structures of language more than the structures of production, the public sphere, or engagement. That is, most of the text examines what it means to be on the inside of the state's controlling structures. We know this is a text about language. The main character works with words. One of the four state ministries is the ministry of Truth, which is our entryway into the world of the novel. However, the introduction to this world is so specific, that the text leaves little space for other parts of the world, existence outside of participating in linguistic manipulations, as Winston, O'Brien, and Syme do. All of the figures presented participate in the state structure; therefore, it is difficult to understand who the production and proliferation of “information” is for. There are the Party members and the Proles. We know the Proles aren't human, so the social life they have is not the intended audience of the Ministry of Truth.

Another point to the primacy of language in the novel is the leveling of distinction between the ruling political movement, which is Ingsoc, to the language that this party is creating, Newspeak (54). The goal of the party is to control behavior and this is represented primarily through control of thinking: “Every year fewer and fewer words, and the range of consciousness always a little smaller” (54). Who's behavior is being controlled? Does the control really exist on the level of just the party members who are already involved in the 'rectification' of language? The following quote would support the assertion that language control and, subsequently, thought control, is necessary if just for the party members themselves: “The eyeless creature at the other table swallowed it fanatically, passionately, with a furious desire to track down, denounce, and vaporize anyone who should suggest that last week the ration had been thirty grams. Syme, too—in some more complex way, involving double-think—Syme swallowed it. Was he, then, alone in the possession of memory?” (1984 60) Both the intellectual Syme and the unintelligent Parsons participate in the manipulation of the linguistic culture at the same time they completely surrender to the pretense of the manipulation, that is, both performing double-think.

The manipulation of information through data takes a center stage given that controlling the present by manipulating the past is the main character's vocation. This speaks to the controlling of the archive. This is precisely the kind of manipulation of an archive, the loss of societal memory that political satire television shows The Daily Show and The Colbert Report call out when a media outlet misrepresents facts in order to make their point. The Fox News organization participates in this. Perhaps this is why the term for controlling language is Newspeak, which could be heard as “News speak”. Was this type of manipulation of information by the news media a concern that Orwell faced in the 1940's? Is he performing a critique of the news establishment of the time, or is this critique simply prescient in describing the current phenomenon?

The main character expresses the concern that the ability to double-think makes inoperable the possession of memory. Memory becomes important for several reasons in the text: first, because the state goes through so much effort to control the archive. The novel's description of the structures mean to control the archive demand a significant suspension of disbelief. How are so many recalls made on every type of publication? Why is a recall even the best option? Why not simply demand that all information products be destroyed after a period? Otherwise, with the proliferation of contradictory records (Let's agree that it is impossible to recall and reprint all newspapers, pamphlets, books, etc.) what is the value of Winston's position? Who even cares to read an old newspaper? How would this newspaper be accessible to the general public after it has been rectified? No, structurally, the way that Winston's vocation has been represented is not workable. Therefore, the whole point of describing his work is describing the control that state places over the archive. The question of controlling an archive and controlling language is a postcolonial concern, much like some of the arguments made in Kincaid's “A Small Place.” The British state is, perhaps, then, notorious when it comes to controlling through language. Syme goes into great detail about how language, especially through its reduction, creates conditions for control.

 The control of the archive is presented as control of memory: “But to trace out the history of the whole period, to say who was fighting whom at any given moment, would have been utterly impossible, since no written record, and no spoken word, ever made mention of any other alignment than the existing one” (35). “If the Party could thrust its hand into the past and say of this or that event, it never happened—that, surely, was more terrifying than mere torture and death” (35). There is in the text a significant conflict with personal memory and imposed state memory (the archive): “He, Winston Smith, knew that Oceania had been in alliance with Eurasia as short a time as four years ago. But where did that knowledge exist? Only in his own consciousness...” (35). Winston possesses his own memories, but these memories contradict the official politically imposed state position, making the personal memory a through crime and subject to the handling by the thought police. In these conditions, memory is subjected to state controls.

In a text by Edmundo Desnoes, "Memories of Underdevelopment," the question isn't whether the state forces one to forget. Rather, the issue is that some people don't remember. Can't remember. Desnoes spends a great deal of time in his novel working out the possibility that some types of people do not possess memory the same as others. They can't remember from one day to the next, which is the very issue that Winston takes issue with when both Syme and Parsons effectively perform ignorance of the fact that chocolate rations were higher one week before, yet they are being told that the current rationing is an increase from previous amounts. The question of memory in these two texts can be related to critiques of communist states: in one case post Cuban revolution and in the second case post Russian revolution.

With regards to the human ability to remember, Nietzsche sees this as the goal nature has set for itself in creating the human race. The ability to make and keep promises, to perform with integrity, to keep one's word, first to herself and, then, to others. These texts politicize awareness, consciousness, knowing what happened yesterday or six months ago. What practices are involved in exercising consciousness? Archives, writing, language. How are these things politicized in this text? How is awareness a moral obligation? Awareness begins to take on moral implications for Winston. He is unable to question the motives and actions of the state because he has no tools for memory. He only knows the poor conditions of his current existence and the only public account for the situation is that things are better today than before. “And though, of course, it grew worse as one's body aged, was it not a sign that this was not the natural order of things, if one's heart sickened at the discomfort and dirt and scarcity, the interminable winters, the stickiness of one's socks, the lifts that never worked, the cold water, the gritty soap, the cigarettes that came to pieces, the food with its strange tastes? Why should one feel it to be intolerable unless one had some kind of ancestral memory that things had once been different?” (61).

So, the text presents the conditions that it is simple, plausible, easy, natural for humans to adjust their understanding in order to explain their current conditions rather than remember or hold to what they previously believed. Believing what is easiest to believe. Just as this text calls into question the morality of reduced consciousness, Descartes also questions the morality of limited perspective and awareness. Both texts present social experiments, playful presentations of social structures. They are forms of play. The goal of play. What is the goal of play? Regardless of the goal, it is irony makes these texts a form of play. The reader is called on to accept that Winston's job is not real. The readers is supposed to question the validity of his job. Hmm. I feel like I am pushing this too much. I like the idea of play, but not of irony yet.

From Nietzsche's On the Genealogy of Morality

            "To breed an animal which is able to make promises—is that not precisely the paradoxical task which nature has set herself with regard to humankind?" (Nietzsche 38)

            "In order to have that degree of control over the future, man must first have learnt to distinguish between what happens by accident and what by design, to think casually, to view the future as the present and anticipate it, to grasp with certainty what is end and what is means, in all, to be able to calculate, compute—and before he can do this, man himself will really have to become reliable, regular, automatic [notwendig], even in his own self-image, so that he, as someone making a promise is, is answerable for his own future!" (Nietzsche 39)

            "That particular task of breeding an animal which has the right to make a promise includes, as we have already understood, as precondition and preparation, the more immediate task of first making man to a certain degree undeviating [notwendig], uniform, a peer amongst peers, orderly and consequently predictable. The immense amount of labour involved in what I have called the 'morality of custom'…" (Nietzsche 39)

            "Let us place ourselves, on the other hand, at the end of this immense process where the tree actually bears fruit, where society and its morality of custom finally reveal what they were simply the means to: we then find the sovereign individualas the ripest fruit on its tree, like only to itself, having freed itself from the morality of custom, an autonomous, supra-ethical individual (because 'autonomous' and 'ethical' are mutually exclusive), in short, we find a man with his own, independent, durable will, who has the right to make a promise—and has a proud consciousness in every muscle of what he has finally achieved and incorporated, an actual awareness of power and freedom, a feeling that man in general has reached completion." (Nietzsche 40)

            "The 'free' man, the possessor of a durable, unbreakable will, thus has his own standard of value: in possession of such a will: viewing others from his own standpoint, he respects or despises; and just as he will necessarily respect his peers, the strong and the reliable (those with the right to give their word­), —that is everyone who makes promises like a sovereign, ponderously, seldom, slowly, and is sparing with his trust, who confers an honor when he places his trust, who gives his word as something which can be relied on, because he is strong enough to remain upright in the face of mishap or even 'in the face of fate'." (Nietzsche 40)


Memorias del subdesarrollo


Notes for 11/8

CLT 361
November 8, 2012
Class Notes
Yesterday:

We spoke about a famous artist, Jackson Pollock, who is an abstract artist.
Today’s class:
Has a house in New York and Stony Brook maintains the house.
His paintings are expensive
What is abstract art?
(expression): fiction, non-fiction, poetry,
Aesthetics
Techniques
material
Abstract
Scientific method
Art is compared to:
(communication): organize, share feelings, content, history, didactic
Material
Practical value
Utilitarian value
Example: journals, articles, critical texts.
Abstract art doesn’t teach us yet it has aesthetics to it.
Non-fiction:  a text that is written where somebody is writing facts and truths - narratives pros that’s trying to present and makes the reader enjoy the story.
Prompts:
Structure:
Images that go with TBK
People images (father, son, God, and devil)
Fyodor- 55 years old father
Dmitri- with two girls
Fydor- with 1st marriage and then 2nd marriage.
Zosima- spiritual leader at a monastery
Zosima- book 3. Chapter 11, near death.
Alyosha and Zosima- Book 6, chapter 1
Alyosha and Grushenka- their relationship
Zosima- book 7, odor
Dmitri- money
Alyosha and Grushenka- boyfriend & girlfriend and Dmitri- book 8
Illyosha  and Alyosha- two little boys
Details:
Annotation of Lawrence Kohlberg’s “Psychological Analysis and Literary Form: A Study of Doubles in Dostoevsky.”
Dostoevsky had autoscopic phenomena
Characters and their psychology (chart)
Analysis:
Summaries of TBK
The author doesn’t always start off the chapters the same way. He doesn’t have the same formula to start the chapters the same way.
Dostoevsky repeated begins the chapter by focusing on a character and then in the next three chapters trying to explains the character relating to society.
Next class:
Prompt 1- Structure
Prompt 2- Thesis
Prompt 3- Analysis
Presentation- Details
Class ends by reading TBK.